says that each son has a sister, but it never says that each son has a different sister. In fact, all nine brothers could share the same sister.
Once you notice this detail, the puzzle becomes much simpler.
The family consists of one father, nine sons, and one daughter who is the sister of all nine boys.
Adding them together gives the correct total of 11 people.
This small difference in wording is what makes the riddle so effective. Our brains naturally look for patterns and often fill in missing